Rekey vs Replace Locks Saskatoon — Which One Do You Actually Need?
Rekey vs replace locks Saskatoon is one of the most common questions our locksmiths get asked — and the answer can save you a significant amount of money. Many homeowners assume they need a full lock replacement when a simple rekey is all that is required. This guide breaks down the difference clearly so you can make the right decision for your home or business in Saskatoon.
What Is Rekeying a Lock?
Rekeying a lock means changing the internal pin configuration inside the lock cylinder so that your old keys no longer work. A locksmith removes the cylinder, replaces the pins with a new combination, and cuts fresh keys to match. The lock hardware itself stays exactly where it is — only the internal mechanism changes.
Rekeying is fast, affordable, and in most situations, just as secure as installing a brand new lock. The process typically takes 15 to 30 minutes per lock and costs significantly less than a full replacement.
What Is Replacing a Lock?
Replacing a lock means removing the entire lock hardware — the cylinder, the bolt mechanism, the exterior trim, and the interior trim — and installing a completely new unit. A lock replacement is the right choice when the existing hardware is damaged, worn out, or when you want to upgrade to a higher security level.
Lock replacement takes slightly longer than rekeying and costs more because you are paying for both labor and new hardware. However, in certain situations it is the only correct solution.
Rekey vs Replace Locks Saskatoon — Side by Side
Cost Rekeying in Saskatoon costs $25 to $75 per lock. Replacing a lock costs $100 to $250 per lock including hardware and labor. If you have three exterior doors, rekeying saves you $200 or more compared to full replacement.
Time Rekeying takes 15 to 30 minutes per lock. A full lock replacement takes 30 to 60 minutes per lock depending on the hardware. Both can typically be completed in a single same-day visit by Locksmith Saskatoon.
Security Level A rekeyed lock is just as secure as it was originally — you are simply changing who has access. A lock replacement can increase your security level if you upgrade to a Grade 1 deadbolt, a high-security lock, or a smart lock.
When Keys Were Lost or Stolen Rekeying is almost always sufficient. Your lock is not compromised — only the key that opens it needs to change. A rekey accomplishes this at a fraction of the cost of replacement.
When a Lock Is Damaged Replacement is the right choice. A damaged, worn, or forced lock cannot be fixed by rekeying — the hardware itself needs to go.
When to Choose Rekeying in Saskatoon
Choose rekeying when:
- You just moved into a new home and don’t know who has copies of the old keys
- You lost your house keys or had them stolen
- A tenant moved out of your rental property in Saskatoon
- You gave a key to a contractor, cleaner, or caregiver and want to revoke access
- You went through a breakup or roommate change
- You want all your doors to open with one key — a locksmith can rekey all locks to match
In all of these situations, your existing lock is in perfectly good condition. The only thing that needs to change is which key opens it. Rekeying accomplishes this faster and for less money than replacement.
When to Choose Lock Replacement in Saskatoon
Choose lock replacement when:
- Your lock is visibly damaged, worn, or malfunctioning
- Your lock was forced, drilled, or tampered with during a break-in
- You want to upgrade to a higher security grade — Grade 1 deadbolt, high-security lock, or smart lock
- Your lock is so old that parts are no longer available for rekeying
- You want keyless entry or smart home integration
- Your insurance policy requires upgraded lock hardware
If you are unsure which category your situation falls into, call Locksmith Saskatoon at 306-994-7336 and we will give you an honest recommendation with no upselling.
The Smart Move After Moving Into a New Home in Saskatoon
If you just bought or rented a home in Saskatoon, rekeying your locks is one of the smartest and most affordable security decisions you can make. You have no way of knowing how many copies of your keys are out there — previous owners, real estate agents, contractors, neighbors. A rekey immediately and completely cuts off access to anyone who had a key before you moved in.
Most Saskatoon homeowners can have all exterior locks rekeyed for $75 to $175 total — a small price for complete peace of mind.
According to the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, changing or rekeying locks is one of the first recommended steps when moving into any previously occupied home.
Can You Rekey Any Lock in Saskatoon?
Most standard residential and commercial locks can be rekeyed. This includes popular brands like Schlage, Kwikset, Weiser, and Baldwin. Some older or heavily worn locks may not be rekeyable if the cylinder is damaged — in those cases replacement is the only option.
Smart locks and electronic locks generally cannot be rekeyed in the traditional sense — but they can be reprogrammed to delete old access codes and add new ones, which achieves the same result.
Call Locksmith Saskatoon for a Free Recommendation
Still not sure whether you need a rekey or a replacement? Call 306-994-7336 and one of our licensed locksmiths will walk you through the right option for your specific situation — with no pressure and no upselling. We offer same-day service across all of Saskatoon.
📞 Call 306-994-7336 — Locksmith Saskatoon
See also our rekey locks service, our lock change service, and our full locksmith services page.
❓ FAQ — RANK MATH SCHEMA
Is it cheaper to rekey or replace locks in Saskatoon?
Rekeying is significantly cheaper. Rekeying costs $25 to $75 per lock in Saskatoon while replacing a lock costs $100 to $250 including hardware and labor. If your lock is in good condition, rekeying is almost always the better financial choice.
Is rekeying as secure as replacing a lock in Saskatoon?
Yes — as long as your existing lock is in good condition. Rekeying changes who has access without changing the security level of the lock itself. If you want to upgrade your security level, a lock replacement with a higher-grade deadbolt is the right choice.
Should I rekey or replace my locks after moving into a new home in Saskatoon?
Rekeying is almost always sufficient and recommended. You have no way of knowing who has copies of the old keys, and rekeying immediately cuts off all previous access. Most Saskatoon homes can be fully rekeyed for $75 to $175 total.
Can all locks be rekeyed in Saskatoon?
Most standard residential and commercial locks can be rekeyed including Schlage, Kwikset, Weiser, and Baldwin. Very old or heavily damaged locks may need replacement instead. Call 306-994-7336 and we will assess your locks honestly.
How long does rekeying take compared to replacing a lock in Saskatoon?
Rekeying takes 15 to 30 minutes per lock. A full lock replacement takes 30 to 60 minutes per lock. Both services are available same-day from Locksmith Saskatoon.
When should I replace instead of rekey my locks in Saskatoon?
Replace your locks when they are damaged, worn out, were forced during a break-in, or when you want to upgrade to a higher security level such as a Grade 1 deadbolt or smart lock. For all other situations, rekeying is the right and more affordable choice.